Gotham Pizza

    1667 1st Avenue, New York, NY 10028
    (212) 828-0888
    MenuTerms and ConditionsPrivacy PolicyCookies PolicyAccessibility

    Gotham Pizza

    Store Information

    Closed
    1667 1st Avenue, New York, NY 10028
    (212) 828-0888

    Menu

    Menu availability may vary based on the time of your order.

    All Day Menu

    Start New Order

    Menu

    All Day Menu
    change category

    Pizza Slices

    Pizza Slices

    🤩

    Popular

    Regular Cheese Slice

    Real Parmigiano-Reggiano cheese.

    $3.50

    Best Regular Cheese Slice in New York, NY

    Margherita Pizza Slice

    Fresh mozzarella, homemade marinara sauce, extra virgin olive oil and fresh basil.

    $4.50

    Best Margherita Pizza Slice in New York, NY

    Pepperoni Pizza Slice

    Pepperoni Slice

    $4.50

    Best Pepperoni Pizza Slice in New York, NY

    White Pizza Slice

    Mozzarella Cheese and Ricotta Cheese

    $4.25

    Best White Pizza Slice in New York, NY

    Buffalo Chicken Pizza Slice

    Buffalo Chicken Cutlet with Ranch Slice

    $5.00

    Best Buffalo Chicken Pizza Slice in New York, NY

    BBQ Chicken Slice

    BBQ Chicken

    $5.00

    Best BBQ Chicken Slice in New York, NY

    Vegetable Slice

    All vegetables

    $5.00

    Best Vegetable Slice in New York, NY

    Square Pizza Slices

    🤩

    Popular

    Grandma Pizza Slice

    Homemade marinara sauce, Mozzarella, Extra virgin olive oil and fresh basil

    $4.00

    Best Grandma Pizza Slice in New York, NY

    Sicilian Slice

    $3.75

    Best Sicilian Slice in New York, NY

    16" Pizza Pies

    🤩

    Popular

    16" Regular Cheese Pizza

    Regular Cheese Pizza

    $21.00

    Best 16" Regular Cheese Pizza in New York, NY

    16" Margherita Pizza

    Fresh mozzarella, homemade marinara sauce, extra virgin olive oil and fresh basil

    $26.00

    Best 16" Margherita Pizza in New York, NY
    🤩

    Popular

    16" Pepperoni Pizza

    Pepperoni Pizza

    $25.00

    Best 16" Pepperoni Pizza in New York, NY

    16" White Pizza

    Mozzarella Cheese, Ricotta Cheese and Olive Oil

    $26.00

    Best 16" White Pizza in New York, NY

    16" Chicken Cutlet Pizza

    Chicken Cutlet Pizza

    $27.00

    Best 16" Chicken Cutlet Pizza in New York, NY

    16" Buffalo Chicken Pizza

    Buffalo Chicken with Ranch Pizza

    $29.00

    Best 16" Buffalo Chicken Pizza in New York, NY

    16" Vegetable Pizza

    All Vegetables Toppings

    $29.00

    Best 16" Vegetable Pizza in New York, NY

    16" BBQ Chicken Pizza

    BBQ Chicken

    $29.00

    Best 16" BBQ Chicken Pizza in New York, NY

    House Special 16" Pie

    Everything on it!

    $31.00

    Regular 16" Pie with 1 Topping

    Real Parmigiano-Reggiano cheese.

    $25.00

    Pepperoni 16" Pie with 1 Topping

    Pepperoni Pizza

    $29.00

    Margherita 16" Pie with 1 Topping

    Fresh mozzarella, Homemade marinara sauce with onions, Extra virgin olive oil and fresh basil

    $30.00

    White 16" Pie with 1 Topping

    Mozzarella Cheese and Ricotta Cheese

    $30.00

    Chicken 16" Pie with 1 Topping

    Chicken Cutlet Pizza

    $31.00

    Buffalo Chicken 16" Pie with 1 Topping

    Buffalo Chicken and Ranch Pizza

    $33.00

    Vegetable 16" Pie with 1 Topping

    All Vegetables Pizza

    $33.00

    12" Pizza Pies

    12" Regular Cheese Pizza

    $15.00

    Best 12" Regular Cheese Pizza in New York, NY

    12" Margherita Pizza

    $19.00

    Best 12" Margherita Pizza in New York, NY

    12" Pepperoni Pizza

    $18.00

    Best 12" Pepperoni Pizza in New York, NY

    12" White Pizza

    $18.00

    Best 12" White Pizza in New York, NY

    12" Chicken Pizza

    $20.00

    Best 12" Chicken Pizza in New York, NY

    12" Buffalo Chicken Pizza

    $21.00

    Best 12" Buffalo Chicken Pizza in New York, NY

    12" Vegetable Pizza

    All Vegetable Toppings

    $21.00

    Best 12" Vegetable Pizza in New York, NY

    12" House Special Pizza

    $22.00

    12" BBQ Chicken Pizza

    BBQ Chicken

    $21.00

    Best 12" BBQ Chicken Pizza in New York, NY

    12" Regular Cheese Pizza with 1 Topping

    $18.00

    12" Margherita Pizza with 1 Topping

    $22.00

    12" Pepperoni Pizza with 1 Topping

    $21.00

    12" White Pizza with 1 Topping

    $21.00

    12" Chicken Pizza with 1 Topping

    $23.00

    12" Buffalo Chicken with 1 Topping

    $24.00

    12" Vegetable Pizza with 1 Topping

    All vegetable toppings.

    $24.00

    Square Pizza Pies

    Grandma Pizza

    Homemade marinara sauce, mozzarella, extra virgin olive oil and fresh basil

    $26.00

    Best Grandma Pizza in New York, NY

    Sicilian Pizza

    Sicilian Pie

    $22.00

    Best Sicilian Pizza in New York, NY

    Grandma Pizza with 1 Topping

    Homemade marinara sauce with onions, Mozzarella, Extra virgin olive oil and fresh basil

    $30.00

    Sicilian Pizza with 1 Topping

    Sicilian Pie

    $26.00

    Garlic Knots

    🤩

    Popular

    4 Garlic Knots

    $2.50

    Best 4 Garlic Knots in New York, NY

    Salads

    House Salad

    Lettuce, tomatoes, cucumber, black olives, onions and carrots. Light-italian dressing on the side

    $8.00

    Best House Salad in New York, NY

    Caesar Salad

    Romaine lettuce, fresh Romano cheese, cucumbers and croutons. Caesar dressing on the side.

    $9.00

    Best Caesar Salad in New York, NY

    Party Size House Salad

    Serves 8-10 people.

    $50.00

    Party Size Caesar Salad

    Serves 8-10 people.

    $60.00

    Beverages

    12 oz. Soda Can

    Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Fanta Orange and Ginger Ale

    $2.00

    Bottled Water 16oz.

    Poland Spring

    $2.00

    2 Liter Soda

    Coke, Diet Coke and Sprite

    $5.00